Best Pokemon Games?

[Красный Мистик]

Personally, I'm a gen 4 guy. I love the Pokemon, the anime, the Sinnoh region in general. Plus, Gen 4 has the Gen 2 remakes and they're pretty good as well.

 

[Yoshi]

Out of the ones I've played, Generation 2.

I haven't played X or Y yet though, and that would probably be even better than GSC, disregarding the Hoenn remakes.

 

[Son Gokū]

Yellow Edition and Emerald Edition.
Best forever...

 

[Doctor Havoc]

Prolly 2 or 4 for me
There just too guuud

 

[Emmeth]

Obviously PokePark 2: Wonders Beyond.

 

[Papasmurf]

Tough to say, but overall my preference lies in Generation 2 and Generation 4. Generation 5 was forgettable and pretty dull other than the lead villain(s) while the second half of Generation 6 is pure milking.

 

[Six Trails]

Agreed with those who said Gen 2 is the best. I don't have much of an interest for anything past Gen 4 personally.

 

[Pyro]

I replay Gold, Silver, Ruby, and Red from time to time. I've wanted to try out Black/White but I'm not sure if I'd enjoy it since it sounds like the whole system has become all about which trait your PKMN has and shit like that. I don't care if my Charmander is lethargic; he's going to beat someone's ass and grind to level up regardless.

 

[SSJ2]

Gen 2 for me. I had the most fun playing it for sure, but that could be due to the fact that I was pretty young. Either way, it's still the game that I enjoy replaying the most.

 

[Doctor Havoc]

Yeah 2 and 4 seem to have great replay value imo
1 is pretty limited and 3 isn't meh with post game
And anything after I haven't really tried

 

[Pyro]

What I really want is a continuing game. As you gain levels, your competition (the NPCs) get stronger too. I know Ruby or whatever did this with the PKMN League, but they only got buffed one time and I need more than that.

 

[Doctor Havoc]

Kp try pokemon rumble free to download from e shop
It's a nice little game a bit limited though

 

[Satsuki]

Pokemon Crystal

 

[Captain Cadaver]

For gameplay, either Gen 2 or 6, the former in terms of post-game material whilst the latter in terms of overall game mechanics (though if including remakes, you could logically replace 2 with 4, especially since the DS doesn't have the limited lifespan of a Gameboy cartridge). Plot-wise, I find Gen 5 is pretty underrated, since along with removing a few constantly recycled tropes of the franchise with it's initial Pokémon League challenge it also had time to be more thought provoking in probing on the moral issue of Pokémon battles.

 

[Uncle Goten]

I've only played the first 3 gens, and the 3rd gen was probably my favourite.

 

[Super Saiyan Overlord1007]

Ah Pokémon one of the many things that made my childhood so epic lol. I haven't played Gen VI yet but I hope to in the near future. But I liked every generation of Pokémon so far but my favorite game has always been Crystal, followed by HeartGold and then Emerald.

Gen 2 (Johto)
Gen 3 (Hoenn)
Gen 4 (Sinnoh)
Gen 1 (Kanto) [Even though this generation is broken in more ways than one, it's still a lot of fun to relive]
Gen 6 (Unova)

 

[Whipedkillsmiled]

Pokemon Fire Red is the one I've played the most. I have the old one's but for some reason I enjoyed this one more

 

[Yusuke-sama]

Gen 2 will always be the best gen IMO. HGSS could have easily taken that spot but the weird designs and changed themes sorta messed it up.

I'm still really nostalgic about Gen 1 as I started playing the series during that gen.

 

[Kyo]

I dig Gen 2 and I also don't mind playing the HGSS remake either. Both definitely ahead of everything else easily, imo. As for the others, Gen 1 hasn't aged well though the remakes are okayish I guess, Gen 3 suffered from the later and much criticized Gen 5 issue of excluding (almost) all the old Pokemon (though I think Gen 5's new additions are far worse) as well as too much water, Gen 4 was fine but I found the story boring and a bit absurd and too ambitious for a Pokemon game, Gen 5 tried to improve in the story department but I failed to make it to like the third town when I actually played it. Can't speak for Gen 6.

 

[Event Horizon]

Gen II
Gen I
Gen III
Gen IV
Gen VI
Gen V