Well said up above Uchiha.
Mystic, while I fully understand your side, I feel as though we can do more to please our current members on vB. Of course I'm also looking to please future members as well, but currently, vB will allow us to implement more features that people have requested.
As I said in the OP, I have absolutely no problem with this site currently, so I'm in agreement with you that the change could be seen as unnecessary, but I want to improve it in every way possible.
As for growth, I will disagree there. We are finally up there on the search "DBZ forum" which is finally gaining us members naturally. I feel like vB will give us the change to raise our ranks on other searches too, for example "Dragon Ball forum" which we don't even currently rank on. If we can continue to improve through customization and SEO, I think we can have a chance to really grow further down the road. That's the main reason why I'm all for this.